Choosing Yourself

I didn’t know it at the time, but the first time I chose myself was also the first time I lost my footing in the world I came from.

I was young.
Young enough to believe that if you followed the rules closely enough, life would hold together.
Young enough to think that doing the “right thing” would protect you.

Unconscious blueprints

After my father died, everything I understood about safety quietly rearranged itself. My siblings were older. They moved forward into adulthood with apparent confidence and certainty. One of them stepped almost overnight into a version of womanhood that looked complete, admirable, approved — marriage, faith, a family, a visible path.

I wanted that.
Not the details, exactly — but the promise underneath it.
Belonging. Approval. A sense that I was doing life correctly.

So when the future began to press for a decision, I stepped into marriage — not because my body knew, but because the blueprint did. This was what you did. This was how you became a “good woman.” There is a particular romantic seduction in that kind of fairytale certainty: the belief that if you move forward, everything else will fall into place.

I remember sitting in the car outside the church on the day of the wedding and saying quietly that I wasn’t ready. I remember being reassured that nerves were normal, that it would be fine. I remember believing that once we stepped forward together, the rest would follow.

It didn’t.

When the blueprint failed

The marriage dissolved daily — not in dramatic ways at first, but in the way sadness became normal. In the way my voice stopped mattering. In the way I cried often and was told there was no problem. In the way responsibility was confused with care, and endurance mistaken for commitment.

When I finally understood that this was not a relationship I wanted — or could — keep repairing, the decision arrived with startling clarity. There was no drama inside me. No bargaining. No hesitation.

I knew I had to leave — for both our sakes.

What I didn’t know was the cost.

Leaving wasn’t just the end of a marriage. It was the end of an identity that had been quietly approved by the people I loved most. The marriage had been supported. The leaving was not. My judgement was questioned. My character was doubted. I was seen as giving up too soon, as being difficult, spoiled, unwilling to pay the price that marriage demanded.

The disapproval didn’t shout.
It settled.
It seeped into everything.

Friends tried to steady me with a line I clung to for years: the people who really know you will know you’re doing this for the right reasons. I held onto it because it helped me understand something quietly devastating — that being loved is not the same as being known — and that judgement is not the same as truth.

What strength concealed

That rupture did something irreversible.

On the outside, I learned strength. Independence. Resolve. I learned that I could survive being misunderstood. I learned that I could walk forward without permission.

On the inside, something else took root.

If the people closest to me could be so certain I was wrong, then maybe there really was something wrong with me. Maybe I was the problem. Maybe I deserved the exile that followed.

So I played the part I’d been handed. I became tough. Cynical. Unbothered. I wore rebellion like armour. I joked about my failures before anyone else could. I learned how to laugh at myself before it could hurt.

It looked like freedom.
It felt like fracture.

The first time you choose yourself — really choose yourself — you will almost always lose something you assumed would come with you.

The threshold

And yet — this is where the paradox lives.

That moment — the one where I chose myself and lost the world I knew — was also the beginning of something truer.

It was the first time I trusted my own knowing over collective approval.
The first time I learned that obedience and goodness are not the same thing.
The first time I understood that being loved, being understood, and being supported do not always travel together.

I didn’t emerge healed.
I emerged honest.

The cost was belonging.
The gain was agency.

It took years to understand that both could be true at once.

If I trace my life back far enough now, I can see that moment clearly — not as failure, not as recklessness, not as rebellion — but as a threshold. The place where adaptation stopped working. The place where compliance began to feel wrong in my body. The place where I learned that sometimes the bravest thing you can do is walk forward without witnesses.

Not everyone who leaves is brave.
Not everyone who stays is weak.

But the first time you choose yourself — really choose yourself — you will almost always lose something you hoped would come with you.

And that loss will shape you.
Not into someone harder.
But into someone more honest about what it costs to live aligned.

A Small Invitation for This Week

Think of a moment when you knew something wasn’t right — not intellectually, but in your body.

Notice what you did next.
Whether you adapted.
Whether you complied.
Or whether you paused.

You don’t have to rewrite your life.
Just notice where your knowing first asked for your trust.


Feeling something land as you read? If you’d like company and structured support as you walk your own season of change, you’re welcome to read more about working with me on the Coaching with Jo-Anne page.

← Back to Notes from Becoming

Scroll to Top